Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 11°C

min temp: 5°C

Search

Bury St Edmunds: Greene King rejects Minister’s ‘tax avoidance’ claim after tribunal ruling

PUBLISHED: 16:54 28 April 2014 | UPDATED: 19:07 28 April 2014

The Greene King brewery in Bury St Edmunds.

The Greene King brewery in Bury St Edmunds.

Archant

Pubs and brewing group Greene King has denied suggestions it has been engaging in tax avoidance after losing the latest round in a battle with HM Revenue & Customs.

The Bury St Edmunds-based company, which says that it pays seven times more in tax than it does in dividends, added that it was considering a further appeal against the ruling.

According to HMRC, a scheme marketed by accountants Ernst & Young in 2003, involving internal loans between group companies, was designed to enable tax relief to be claimed on interest paid to another group company without that other company paying tax on the income it received.

However, the Upper Tribunal for tax affairs has now upheld a lower tier ruling that the scheme does not work.

HMRC says this means that Greene King and a number of other major companies which have also been using the scheme will between them have to pay an additional £36million in tax.

In an HMRC statement yesterday, Exchequer Secretary David Gauke said: “The vast majority of taxpayers play by the rules and the Government will continue to take tough action to tackle the minority who seek to avoid their responsibilities.

“HMRC wins 80% of the cases it takes to court and this win, in a very complex case, sends another clear message to tax avoiders. Anyone who gets involved in tax avoidance schemes is playing with fire. HMRC will pursue those involved through the courts, ensuring it collects the taxes that are due.”

However, Greene King, a member of the EADT/EDP Top100 listing of the 100 largest companies in Suffolk and Norfolk, said that the Upper Tribunal judge had accepted the the dispute was about the correct treatment of a loan for tax purposes and not a case of tax avoidance.

“Greene King has been paying its taxes for 214 years and has always taken these responsibilities very seriously,” the company said in a statement.

“We are a major contributor to the Treasury with a third of our turnover, or £375m, paid to HMRC in various forms of tax, in the last year alone. This is seven times what we pay to our shareholders in dividends.

“Over and above this, we occasionally take specific tax advice from experts, such as Ernst & Young in this case, about other areas of potential tax paid by Greene King.

“In this case, the Upper Tribunal court has disagreed with the advice we received and we are therefore currently considering whether to appeal this decision. The Upper Tribunal judge expressly said this was a question of correct accounting treatment of a loan, not tax avoidance.”

1 comment

  • The amounts of VAT and excise duty spuriously included in turnover are neither here nor there. The relevant comparison is between the amount of Corporation Tax paid, and the amount of dividends to shareholders.

    Report this comment

    John Green

    Tuesday, April 29, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

It was a case of déjà vu for an Ipswich Hospital practitioner who recently found herself caring for newborn twin girls - 24 years after she looked after their father.

Orwell Park School near Ipswich has held its annual charity fun run.

A fundraising page to help care for horses seized by welfare organisations in Paper Mill Lane near Ipswich has raised more than £3,400.

With festival season nearly upon us, can you name all the acts performing at this year’s Latitude festival from their album covers?

Dear Mum,

Bringing my newborn daughter home from the hospital 10 years ago was terrifying.

An 86-year-old man from Ipswich who was reported missing to police earlier today has been found safe and well.

Care home staff in Ipswich have been praised for their “tireless” dedication by their new manager.

More than 20 level crossings across Suffolk could be closed or modified to improve safety, efficiency and reliability on the county’s train lines.

Clacton MP Douglas Carswell has announced he is leaving UKIP to become an independent MP after helping the party to achieve Brexit.

A 15-year-old girl from Ipswich who was reported missing to police this morning has been found “safe and well”.

Most read

Most commented

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Topic pages

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter
MyDate24 MyPhotos24