Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 17°C

min temp: 13°C


Ipswich: Ben Gummer vows to take Scott Nicholls case up with justice secretary

15:55 26 February 2013

Emma Harold and Kate Wasyluk were killed when road menace Scott Nicholls crashed into them in Foxhall Road in February 2009. Beccy Rutter, right, survived but was left with serious, life-changing injuries

Emma Harold and Kate Wasyluk were killed when road menace Scott Nicholls crashed into them in Foxhall Road in February 2009. Beccy Rutter, right, survived but was left with serious, life-changing injuries

©Archant Photographic 2009

AN Ipswich MP has vowed to speak to the justice secretary after readers called for a change in the law regarding criminals in need of treatment in mental health hospitals.


It comes as the families of Emma Harold and Kate Wasyluk – killed in a road crash on February 21, 2009 – questioned why the driver, Scott Nicholls, served just over a month in prison for taking two lives.

Nicholls was released on Friday, the day after the fourth anniversary of the horrific Foxhall Road crash, after serving the majority of his four-year sentence in a mental health hospital.

He was only discharged from hospital into jail in January – a month before his release date.

When he ploughed into the friends and Emma’s younger sister Beccy, Nicholls was speeding, over the legal alcohol limit and had traces of heroin and ecstasy in his system.

Emma, 26 and 25-year-old Kate were killed while Beccy was left with life-changing injuries.

Kate’s brother Remy Wasyluk has called for a change in the law, demanding that criminals deemed unfit to serve in prison should be treated in hospital and then released into jail to start their sentence.

A poll on The Star’s website attracted more than 450 responses with an overwhelming 87% of respondents agreeing that the law must be changed.

And Ipswich MP Ben Gummer said he would be raising the matter with cabinet minister Chris Grayling.

“I am concerned about this and will be raising it with the Secretary of State for Justice,” Mr Gummer said.

“The law should be just and fair for victims of crime.”

Mr Wasyluk added: “It’s good to hear that 87% of readers agree with me.

“It proves that my thoughts are rational and not just born out of a sense of injustice.

“I’d now love to hear a solid argument from the judicial service as to how they feel the law currently punishes the guilty.

“Continuously in our society we witness examples of how the perpetrators of crime are protected and supported.

“There never seems to be any real action to punish people and make them pay for the crimes they commit.

“With no such deterrent I think certain people will go about their lives with a selfish regard for anyone around them, leading to more people senselessly getting knocked down and killed on our roads. “With almost 90% of the poll agreeing with me I look forward to hearing the views of the justice secretary.”

Related articles



  • Why Ben Gummer is getting involved i want to know, normally he is happy to sit on the fence. And it is no good him talking to the justice system because they are probably the biggest joke in this country next to the government. We can see by the comments of local people there is uproar over this but nothing will come of it because the powers that be, including the ipswich star will want to brush it under the table.

    Report this comment


    Tuesday, February 26, 2013

  • Makes me sick how soft this country is on criminals. He should have got life at a hard prison like Shawshank! Not these holiday camps that we call prisons now.

    Report this comment


    Tuesday, February 26, 2013

  • Gummer should resign.

    Report this comment

    PC Plod

    Tuesday, February 26, 2013


    Report this comment


    Tuesday, February 26, 2013

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Alcohol was repeatedly sold to underage drinkers in Ipswich

An Ipswich man has pleaded guilty to selling alcohol to children from his shop.

The homeless in Ipswich tuck in to a hot meal at the Ipswich Winter Night Shelter. Photograph Simon Parker

The Ipswich Winter Night Shelter has launched a drive for volunteers ahead of opening its doors on December 2.

Paul Clement, chief executive of Ipswich Central

A major conference aimed at pushing ahead with dramatic changes to Ipswich town centre is to be held at the end of this month.

Motorists were sent on a diversion nearly 30miles (47.7km) long

We all bemoan the diversions which close the highways and byways of Suffolk when roadworks are set up.

The Northgate High School team competing at a regional heat in Ford Dunton

Northgate High School pupils are preparing for a grand prix experience as they compete in the finals of the Greenpower International Kit Car competition.

Work is being stepped up at hospitals in Suffolk and north Essex to deal with “bed blocking” after new figures revealed more than 38,000 “bed days” have been lost because of the issue since 2012.

The area in Clarkson Street where two gangs fought on September 23

An Ipswich mother-of-two has told of how she was left terrified after getting caught up in the middle of fighting between groups of young men wielding bricks, lumps of wood and an axe.

Sharon Halls and Daniel Compton's baby, Evie

The mother of a premature baby born 12 weeks early in the Dominican Republic has said they are not expecting to travel home before December.

Nick Alston, Essex Police & Crime Commissioner.

Up to 15 police stations in Essex could be axed as the county’s force admits its property estate is “haemorrhaging money”.

The Orwell Bridge

There have been a number of crashes on the county’s roads this morning.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages