Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 8°C

min temp: 7°C


Ipswich: Couple barred from keeping dogs for 15 years after RSPCA prosecution over their Newfoundland

15:28 23 January 2014

Winston, the Newfoundland who belonged to Allen Forsdyke and Mary McEvoy

Winston, the Newfoundland who belonged to Allen Forsdyke and Mary McEvoy


An Ipswich couple have been banned from keeping dogs for 15 years after admitting a string of offences involving their five-year-old Newfoundland.


Ipswich magistrates heard that after seeing the state of Allen Forsdyke and Mary McEvoy’s pet Winston, a vet said: “In my 20 years as a vet, I have never seen a dog presented for such an examination with such advanced skin disease. This looks to have been going on for a long period of time.”

Forsdyke and McEvoy, of Shakespeare Road, Ipswich, bought Winston as a puppy, but lost their jobs and were unable to pay for the care he needed.

The pair were sentenced after each pleaded guilty to two counts of causing unnecessary suffering and three counts of failing to ensure the welfare of an animal.

At their sentencing it was said that Winston had long-term problems that needed considerable care, which Forsdyke, 42, and McEvoy, 48, could not afford.

Prosecutor Hugh Rowland said RSPCA Inspector Marc Niepold visited the couple’s home on August 15 last year and saw Winston was unwell. Two vets subsequently examined the Newfoundland.

There was evidence of a lack of muscle and overgrown nails, indicative of a lack of exercise, the court heard.

The dog was severely depressed and had an eye infection. It also had eczema, dermatitis, hair loss over its entire body and a flea infestation, as well as an infection and inflammation in its ears. Winston also gave off an unpleasant “yeasty” odour denoting a skin condition, Mr Rowland said.

Many of the ailments had been present for at least two or three months. As a result, Winston was said to have been left in a weak and debilitated state. Forsdyke and McEvoy appeared to have tried to use a homeopathic treatment to get rid of the mange, although this did not work. A flea shampoo was also used, but it would have only washed the parasites off, not killed them.

Magistrates were told Winston was now a lot better after treatment and had been signed over to the RSPCA.

Ian Duckworth, representing the couple, said: “This is not a straightforward cruelty case, or even neglect case.

“She (McEvoy) acknowledges that had things been better financially, I think they could have undertaken the necessary treatment. What is abundantly clear is that this animal has inherent conditions.”

In addition to their 15-year disqualification from keeping dogs, Forsdyke and McEvoy were given 12-month community orders with 120-hour work requirements. Forsdyke was also given a supervision order.

They must each pay £300 costs and £60 to the victims’ fund.



  • Banned from keeping dogs for 15 years? Just how do you stop someone keeping dogs, you can buy a dog from a breeder in any part of the UK, how do they check if you are banned. We bought a puppy from a farm, the breeder was justifiably proud of the breeding records, and was anxious that we could look after the puppy, but they had no facilities to check us out. Nonsense!

    Report this comment


    Thursday, January 23, 2014

  • They should not be allowed to have children either.

    Report this comment

    Robert Manning

    Thursday, January 23, 2014

  • The people of Whitton would grass them up, this couple are very disliked by the whole estate.

    Report this comment

    Lee Davies

    Thursday, January 23, 2014

  • I recently made a comment on a similar court case involving a horse. It is not a picture of the animals we need but one of the offenders. It will not stop such people from aquiring an animal in defiance of the ban but people will be able report them, if they know what they look like, to the authorities.

    Report this comment

    The original Victor Meldrew

    Thursday, January 23, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Westgate Street, Ipswich.

Fire crews have been called to a suspected gas leak in Westgate Street, Ipswich.

Artist's impression of the homes there were proposed for lane close to Poplar Lane, Sproughton.

Babergh district councillors last night said they had voted against officers’ advice and refused a 475-home development on the edge of Ipswich because its design was “appalling”.

Police at the scene of the alleged robbery

A 25-year-old man from south London who was arrested following a robbery at a convenience store in Claydon has been charged.

On going work at Ipswich Station

Work on a near-£2million refurbishment of Ipswich railway station has started – and is set to continue until August next year.

Nick Alexander, who died in the Bataclan massacre, in Paris, France. Photo: Foreign & Commonwealth Office/PA Wire.

The singer from the Eagles of Death Metal has paid tribute to Nick Alexander for his selflessness during the massacre at the Paris theatre where 89 people died almost two weeks ago.

Juliet Bellfield's charity committee has raised almost £1m for cancer care

Fellow fundraisers have paid tribute to the “inspirational” leadership of a Suffolk woman who helped generate almost £1million for cancer care.

Ipswich Crown Court.

A 43-year-old man accused of sexually assaulting a seven-year-old girl has told a court he drove off in his car when he was confronted about the allegations by her father because he did not want a fight.

An artist's impression of the restored brewery.

This is a first look at how a refurbished and converted former Tolly Cobbold brewery will be at the centre of a new housing development on Ipswich waterfront.

Colin Noble

Suffolk County Council could consider increasing its element of council tax bills for the first time since 2010 following the Chancellor’s Autumn Statement.

The A134 at Assington.

This year’s death toll on Suffolk’s roads is now the worst since 2009 after six fatalities in the last 13 days, according to police figures.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages

Local business directory

Suffolk's trusted business finder

Property search

e.g. Oxford or NW3
Powered by Zoopla

Digital Edition

Read the Ipswich Star e-edition today E-edition

Great British Life

Great British Life
MyDate24 MyPhotos24