Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 11°C

min temp: 1°C

Search

Poll: Can a single test, on a single day of your childhood, significantly affect your life chances? We look at how the 11-plus shaped futures

09:20 21 June 2014

Sheila Hardy

Sheila Hardy

Archant

If that test is the 11-plus, then the answer could well be yes, according to university researchers. Sheena Grant studies the evidence.

shares
Angela Carter, a former hairdresser who went on to become vice-principal of Otley College before quitting to become a life/management coach. Angela Carter, a former hairdresser who went on to become vice-principal of Otley College before quitting to become a life/management coach.

It’s almost 50 years since Henry Neale sat the 11-plus and narrowly missed out on a grammar school place but the emotions stirred by talking about the test and the selective education system it represented haven’t diminished over time.

“I remember weeping into the exam paper,” he says. “You knew how important it was because the teachers kept telling you. I struggled on the day because I was so nervous and wasn’t confident with maths. Also, you knew that if you didn’t pass the 11-plus you would probably end up at the local secondary modern, which had a terrible reputation. Kids were constantly in trouble with the police and the school was in a really rough area. You would be confined to the education scrapheap and the only way out would be a hard, physical dockyard job. How on Earth can you perform at your best in an exam under those circumstances?”

Henry, who now lives in Suffolk, was heartbroken when the results came through. His only hope of avoiding the feared secondary modern in the south coast city of his birth was to get a place at the local technical high school.

“If you were a borderline case you could go for an interview there to see if they would take you,” he says. “That’s what I did. They also reviewed your 11-plus performance to get an idea of your aptitude for the sort of technical education they offered, which was heavily skewed towards subjects such as technical drawing, metalwork, brickwork, physics and chemistry. There was no emphasis on cultural or artistic stuff, although we did do O and A levels. I’m certain that failing the 11-plus had a catastrophic effect on my self-esteem. I wasn’t remotely technically minded and felt like a fish out of water at the technical high school but anything was better than the secondary modern.”

Emilia Del Bono, lead researcher at the University of Essex in a study on the long term effects of grammar school educationEmilia Del Bono, lead researcher at the University of Essex in a study on the long term effects of grammar school education

The disparities of the system were obvious to Henry, even as a child.

“You were constantly made to feel like a failure,” he says. “Our school football team played against the grammar school team. We couldn’t believe the facilities they had. It was palatial compared to our school. God knows how it compared to the secondary modern.”

It wasn’t just that the grammar school was better resourced – it was clear to Henry it had a different calibre of teacher too.

“Our teachers were completely dismissive of us,” he says. “There were certain members of staff who should never have been anywhere near a school. Many were coming to the end of their careers. They just wanted to get through the day, go home and wait for retirement.”

Angela Carter, a former hairdresser who went on to become vice-principal of Otley College before quitting to become a life/management coachAngela Carter, a former hairdresser who went on to become vice-principal of Otley College before quitting to become a life/management coach

After doing A levels, Henry went on to college and had a career in the media but still feels the injustice of the past.

“If I had gone to grammar school I’m sure I would have been treated differently,” he says. “I would probably have gone on to university and perhaps even a higher paid job, if I had wanted one. There were a lot of very bright people who didn’t pass the 11-plus. I’m glad that system has, largely, gone.”

Henry’s memories of selective education in the 1960s are particularly damning but recently-published research from the University of Essex suggests many of his observations may be correct.

The study, carried out and published by the university’s Institute for Social and Economic Research, looked at the long-term impacts of the grammar school system on borderline 11-plus passers. Its findings appear to support claims that success or failure in the test can have a major impact on a child’s whole future.

In The Long Term Effects of Attending an Elite School: Evidence from the UK, Dr Emilia Del Bono and Professor Damon Clark tracked the progress of 12,500 Aberdeen-born children from ante-natal care to age 50. The research found that for girls, grammar school led to an average of almost one whole additional year of full-time education, increasing their chances of getting A levels by almost 25%. Grammar school education led to a 20% increase in gross income, a 10% increase in wages and a significantly decreased fertility rate, by an average of 0.5 children per family. Men who attended grammar school had more than a year extra full-time education, and doubled the probability of receiving a degree, but researchers found no effect on income, wages or fertility by age 50.

A second study, carried out by researchers from the University of Bristol, University of Bath and the Institute of Education, University of London, found the English grammar school system widens the gap between rich and poor.

In ‘Selective schooling systems increase inequality’ Simon Burgess, Matt Dickson and Lindsey Macmillan analysed pay of more than 2,500 people born between 1961 and 1983 and found a much bigger gap between the wages of the highest and lowest paid individuals born in areas with a selective education system than they did in similar local authorities that had introduced comprehensive schools.

“Schools with high ability pupils are more likely to attract and retain high quality teaching staff,” says lead researcher Prof Simon Burgess. “This puts pupils who miss out on a grammar school place at an immediate disadvantage. They will also be part of lower ability peer groups, which affects their chances of succeeding at school too.”

•How did the 11-plus affect you? Write to ealife at 30 Lower, Brook Street, Ipswich, IP4 1AN.

In Essex, pupils can still opt to take the test for a place at one of eight remaining grammar schools. A future edition of ealife will look at the measures some families will take to try and ensure success.

shares
Nearly 14,000 people flocked to the Felixstowe Spa Pavilion during the first three months of its re-opening. Photo: Su Anderson

The new owners of Felixstowe’s Spa Pavilion are celebrating after it was revealed thousands have flocked to see shows at the recently re-opened venue.

A motorist drove into a wall in Sidegate Lane, Ipswich, on Wednesday 27th April.

An alleged drink driver crashed his BMW 525 estate into a wall and collided with three other vehicles in Sidegate Lane yesterday afternoon.

Keith Sadler at his home in Stowmarket.

A singer-songwriter from Suffolk whose life turned in a different direction due to health problems has released an album.

Candidates Tim Passmore, Cath Pickles, Helen Korfanty, Terence Carter and Simon Tobin all signed the pledge.

All five candidates running for Suffolk’s police and crime commissioner role have signed a pledge to end sexual violence against women and girls in the county.

Kevin Keen, who has left his post as manager of Colchester United this afternoon

On Sleeping Giants this week, we discuss Colchester United’s next move, the Whizzinator, sporting cheats and painful moments.

Suffolk County Council's chief executive Deborah Cadman

The union representing the largest number of staff at Suffolk County Council has called for all employees at the authority to be given the same pay rise as chief executive Deborah Cadman.

Joe and Ruth Lubbock celebrate their 75th wedding anniversary this week.

Suffolk couple Joseph and Ruth Lubbock are today celebrating their 75th wedding anniversary. LYNNE MORTIMER meets them as they mark three-quarters of a century as Mr and Mrs Lubbock.

Dog walking

Weather for the weekend is looking chilly but fair so why not head out for a stroll with your canine friend and enjoy some Suffolk pub hospitality while you’re there.

crazy-weather-in-suffolk-today_2016-4-26_31626_68671

Changeable is the best way to describe the weather this week, with bright sunshine one moment and hail storms the next - but expect warmer days this bank holiday weekend.

The former Croydons building

Hopes are rising that up-market Jack Wills could soon be on its way to Ipswich town centre.

Most read

Most commented

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Topic pages

Streetlife

Newsletter Sign Up

Great British Life

Great British Life
MyDate24 MyPhotos24