Overcast

Overcast

max temp: 13°C

min temp: 11°C

Search

Why the case for an increase in interest rates is anything but clear cut

PUBLISHED: 13:34 02 November 2017 | UPDATED: 13:34 02 November 2017

Mortgages payments are set to rise following an increase in interest rates by the Bank of England.
Picture: Getty Images/iStockphoto

Mortgages payments are set to rise following an increase in interest rates by the Bank of England. Picture: Getty Images/iStockphoto

Pogonici

The Bank of England’s decision to raise interests comes as little surprise – but the case for an increase looks highly questionable.

True, the latest data on economic growth was slightly stronger than expected, with GDP rising by 0.4% during the third quarter, but this hardly represents the kind of “overheating” which would normally be expected to result in a rise in rates.

Also, although it is well above the Government’s 2% target, the current inflation rate of 3% is still well short of two previous spikes seen since the financial crisis of 2008.

On those occasions, Bank of England policymakers took the view that increasing rates would threaten economic growth and that the factors behind the rise in inflation would naturally unwind. This proved correct, with inflation even falling briefly into negative territory two years ago.

With the increase in inflation over the past 12 months being largely attributable to the rise in the cost of imports, due to the fall in the value of the pound since the Brexit vote, there is good reason to believe that inflation would have again fallen back without a rise in rates.

It would be different were there any sign of wages starting to follow prices higher but, in fact, annual growth in pay is continuing to lag well behind inflation.

There is, it is true, some evidence of consumers responding to this by borrowing more, in order to make ends meet or to pay for luxuries, and the Bank of England has, rightly, expressed concern over the level of household indebtedness.

However, seeking to address this through an increase in interest rates is something of a blunt instrument. If the lessons of the last financial crisis have been truly learned, the bank should be intervening to control lending in a more targeted way.

The truth is that the recent warnings from Bank of England governor Mark Carney and other members of the bank’s rate-setting committee of an early increase in rates became self-fulfilling.

The markets factored in a rate rise, so supporting the value of the pound, and had the bank confounded this expectation sterling would have gone into reverse once more, so adding to the inflationary pressure.

Having been accused of over-reacting to the Brexit vote by cutting rates, to head-off an expected slowdown which did not materialise, it might be argued that it is now prudent for the bank to reverse the cut.

But its talk of two further increases to take the base rate to 1%, even if phased over two to three years, sounds premature give the continuing uncertainty over the outcome of Brexit - and the fact that a generation of borrowers has grown up with no experience of anything other than rock-bottom rates.

A Suffolk woman forked out almost £200 a week for domestic care despite agency workers cutting visits short, a government watchdog has found.

Businesses and families across Suffolk and Essex were waiting to hear on Wednesday what Chancellor the Exchequer Philip Hammond’s Budget will mean for them.

One of the most notorious mobile phone notspots in East Anglia should have better connections with the 21st century within the next few weeks.

A charity chief is calling for so-called fix rooms to be brought to Suffolk for addicts to inject safely as figures show the number of people dying from drug misuse in the county has doubled in the last 10 years.

The ActivLives Community Games return to Ipswich this Friday, to help get over 50s into sport and regular activity in a social environment.

Ipswich-based Trianon Music Group has just completed its 2017 series of concerts – but it is already preparing for next year.

The waterfront has played host to a number of vessels and ships over the years, but here we look back to 1982 when makeshift rafts were put to the test and raced around the docks.

The 1970s heartthrob David Cassidy has died at the age of 67, his family has reported.

An elderly couple’s car managed to get stuck up an embankment after it crashed into a sign on the A14 westbound slip road for the Copdock Interchange this evening.

Paramedics have treated an elderly woman for serious injuries after a crash in Hadleigh.

Most read

Show Job Lists

Topic pages

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter
MyDate24 MyPhotos24