Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 8°C

min temp: -1°C


Melton ‘Cheese wedge’ homes refused

PUBLISHED: 19:30 26 November 2018 | UPDATED: 10:35 28 November 2018

A CGI view of the proposed homes as seem across the meadow from the riverside end of the site at Melton Hill. Picture: HOOPERS

A CGI view of the proposed homes as seem across the meadow from the riverside end of the site at Melton Hill. Picture: HOOPERS


Controversial plans for 100 homes in Melton likened to “cheese wedges” by critics have been refused planning permission in the latest twist of the long-running saga.

Developers Active Urban Woodbridge Ltd lodged plans for 100 homes on the former Suffolk Coastal District Council offices in Melton Hill at the end of last year.

The proposals were narrowly given the backing of the council’s planning committee in April, with the final conditions delegated for approval to Philip Ridley, the council’s head of planning services.

But the developers opted to withdraw the application before the conditions were approved and submit a fresh one in order to present an amended application over the summer.

The plans remained the same, except for an application for Vacant Building Credit – a scheme to encourage applicants to redevelop empty buildings, and meant the number of affordable homes proposed were reduced from 32 to 15.

During Monday’s planning committee the plans were unanimously refused.

Councillor Susan Harvey said: “On what was our own site we should be developing affordable housing at its full level.”

Planning officers said the length of time the buildings had been empty meant it was not eligible for the scheme, although David Hughes from Active Urban disagreed with the assessment.

Councillor Michael Gower said: “It’s only been vacant because it’s a complex site and I think this is another example of gaining [from the] planning system where a new bit of legislation for something completely different is being used to allow developers to get out of their responsibilities.”

Mr Hughes said the Vacant Building Credit was not an available option at the time of the original application, and pointed to a lack of interest from registered providers of affordable housing being an issue.

He added: “Those registered providers are not coming forward with levels they were previously.

“Our viability issues would be resolved through the Vacant Building Credit. We didn’t wish to withdraw it but it would have meant the scheme would not have been delivered without that action being taken.”

Mr Hughes refused to be drawn on whether the firm will appeal the decision or submit a fresh application.

Opinion: A risky strategy backfired?

Withdrawing an application which only narrowly gained committee backing was always going to be a risky decision, but it is one which may have backfired for the Melton homes developers.

Of course, we don’t know how conversations between Mr Ridley and Active Urban were going on behind closed doors, but the fact that the committee could only back it by a casting vote in April must have provided warning signs.

In fairness, the developers had no other option if they wanted to reduce the number of affordable homes, but Monday’s decision now means they have no firm plans on the table.

At least the previous application, which would in all likelihood have been approved once the conditions were sorted would have delivered it some income even if the profit margin was much less than on an open-market property.

Uncertainty now surrounds the future of the plans, but for now locals can breathe a sigh of relief.

A police officer intervened in a row between members of two rival groups in Ipswich town centre a few hours before 17-year-old Tavis Spencer-Aitkens was stabbed to death, it has been alleged.

A teenager has been arrested on suspicion of attempted sexual assault following reports of an attack on a woman in an Ipswich street.

Yates in Ipswich was packed at the weekend with many dancing, drinking and having a laugh. Do you recognise anyone in the pictures?

Police have located a 15-year-old boy who was missing from his Ipswich home for a month.

Rail passengers hoping to make a weekend rail trip to London from East Anglia at the beginning of 2019 are facing three more months of disruption and replacement bus journeys.

A nativity scene outside a church has been cruelly vandalised for the second time this festive season.

All lines were blocked after a lorry collided with a railway bridge between Ipswich and Stowmarket.

A project which is thought to be the first of its kind in the UK will see students get first hand experience of the construction industry, without having to leave the comfort of their college campus.

The Suffolk Blue Cross centre have put together a guide of what festive treats you can/can’t feed your dog and what health implications they could have.

Train services are suspended between Ipswich and Felixstowe due to a signal fault on the line.

Most read

Hot Jobs

Show Job Lists

Topic pages

Newsletter Sign Up

Ipswich Star daily newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

MyDate24 MyPhotos24