UK: Criticism for cardinal who branded gay marriage proposals as “madness”

UK: A Catholic cleric who hit out at the “madness” of the government’s gay marriage plans was condemned today for “scaremongering”.

Cardinal Keith O’Brien, the leader of the Catholic Church in Scotland, accused the coalition of trying to “redefine reality” and claimed the proposals were a “grotesque subversion of a universally accepted human right.”

But his comments were roundly criticised this morning amid fears the outburst would fuel prejudice.

In an article for a Sunday national newspaper, Cardinal O’Brien wrote: “Since all the legal rights of marriage are already available to homosexual couples, it is clear that this proposal is not about rights, but rather is an attempt to redefine marriage for the whole of society at the behest of a small minority of activists.

“Same-sex marriage would eliminate entirely in law the basic idea of a mother and a father for every child. It would create a society which deliberately chooses to deprive a child of either a mother or a father.

“Other dangers exist. If marriage can be redefined so that it no longer means a man and a woman but two men or two women, why stop there? Why not allow three men or a woman and two men to constitute a marriage, if they pledge their fidelity to one another?”

Plans to introduce civil gay marriages have divided the Conservative party and put David Cameron on a collision course with a number of religious leaders.

Most Read

Cardinal O’Brien’s attack was the most outspoken attack to date.

But the Prime Minister is a “passionate” advocate of the change, telling his party two years ago he supported gay marriage “because I am a Conservative”.

Margot James, the first openly lesbian Conservative MP, criticised the “apocalyptic language” used by the Cardinal and accused him of “scaremongering”

“I think it is a completely unacceptable way for a prelate to talk,” she told BBC 1’s Andrew Marr Show.

“I think that the Government is not trying to force Catholic churches to perform gay marriages at all. It is a purely civil matter.”

She added: “I think this sort of scaremongering is what it is, it is just scaremongering.”

Labour’s Deputy Leader Harriet Harman said she hopes the comments would not end up “fuelling or legitimising prejudice.”

“We have had prejudice, discrimination and homophobia for hundreds of years, that doesn’t make it right,” she told the show.

“I don’t want anybody to feel that this is a licence for whipping up prejudice.”

Earlier this week the Home Office defended the plans after Tory MP Peter Bone called them “completely nuts”.

A Home Office spokeswoman said the Government believed that “if a couple love each other” and want to commit to a life together they should “have the option of a civil marriage irrespective of their sexual orientation”.

Equalities minister Lynne Featherstone is due to launch a consultation on the plans later this this month.

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter